Easy 3 Ingredient Oreo S’mores

These Oreo s’mores have everything you want in a campfire treat, with a little extra crunch. Twist open an Oreo, add a piece of milk chocolate and a marshmallow, then slide the tray under the broiler. As soon as the marshmallow turns golden, press the other cookie half on top and watch the chocolate start to melt around the edges.

They’re an easy movie-night dessert, especially when everyone wants something sweet and you have half a pack of Oreos in the cupboard. This recipe makes 12 little s’mores, and you can make as few as you like.

This post may contain affiliate links which helps me keep this blog alive, questions? View the privacy policy.

The 3 Ingredients You’ll Need

  • Oreos. Regular chocolate Oreos give you a crisp cookie and a thin layer of vanilla creme. Twist each one gently so the filling stays mostly on one side.
  • Milk chocolate. Break a thin chocolate bar into pieces about as wide as the cookies. A thick chunk takes longer to soften and can slide off when you sandwich the cookies.
  • Regular marshmallows. One per cookie makes a gooey center. Set each marshmallow on its side so it sits lower and is less likely to tip.

How to Make Oreo S’mores in the Oven

Set an oven rack about 6 inches below the broiler and preheat the broiler. Use a broiler-safe metal baking sheet. While it heats, split the Oreos and set the plain halves aside within reach. Put the filled halves on the sheet, then stack a piece of chocolate and a marshmallow on each one.

Broil until the tops of the marshmallows turn light golden. Start checking at about 20 seconds and keep your eyes on the tray the whole time. Once the tops start to brown, they can darken in seconds. Pull the tray out and gently press the reserved halves on top while the marshmallows are still soft. Give them a minute to cool before serving.

Tips for the Gooey Middle

  • Keep the toppings centered. A piece of chocolate that fits inside the cookie’s edge gives the marshmallow a level place to sit.
  • Go by color. Broilers vary. If the back row browns first, take the pan out, remove those s’mores with a spatula, and return the rest to the oven briefly.
  • Press lightly. Push the cookie lid down just enough to spread the marshmallow to the edge. The wafers can crack if you squeeze too hard.

Easy Variations

  • Dark chocolate Oreo s’mores. Swap the milk chocolate for a thin piece of semisweet chocolate for a less sweet bite.
  • Peanut butter cup s’mores. Replace the chocolate square with a thin peanut butter cup.
  • Golden Oreo s’mores. Use Golden Oreos with milk chocolate for a vanilla-cookie version.

Can You Make Oreo S’mores Ahead?

Split the cookies and portion the chocolate in advance, then toast and assemble just before serving. For a party, broil them in batches so each tray goes out warm. Once any leftovers have cooled completely, keep them in an airtight container at room temperature and enjoy them the next day. The marshmallow will be chewier after it cools.

3-Ingredient Oreo S’mores Recipe

Crunchy Oreo wafers, milk chocolate, and golden marshmallows make bite-size indoor s’mores for movie night or an easy party dessert.

Yield 12 s’mores
Prep time About 10 minutes
Broil time About 20–60 seconds

Ingredients

  • 12 regular Oreo cookies
  • 12 small pieces milk chocolate, from a thin chocolate bar
  • 12 regular marshmallows

Instructions

  1. Position an oven rack about 6 inches below the broiler and preheat the broiler. Set out a broiler-safe metal baking sheet.
  2. Twist apart the Oreos. Set the plain halves aside and place the creme-covered halves on the baking sheet, creme side up.
  3. Add a piece of milk chocolate to each base. Set a marshmallow on its side on top of each piece of chocolate.
  4. Broil for about 20–60 seconds, watching continuously. Remove the tray as soon as the marshmallow tops are light golden.
  5. Gently press a reserved wafer on each marshmallow. Let the s’mores cool for a minute, then serve warm.

Recipe note Use a bare broiler-safe pan or line it with foil. Parchment and silicone baking mats can be damaged under direct broiler heat.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *